Have you ever been a part of a small group where the bible study felt like a pooling of unfounded opinions, a winding road to nowhere, or a painful root canal?
A short while ago, I came to my own conclusions that small group “bible study”, where a group goes through a fill-in-the blank type study of Scripture, on the spot, just doesn’t work.
Now, when I say that, I’m referring to a specific type of small group, probably the most popular type today.
I’m not talking about a group of men or women that decide they are going to get together and really get into Scripture, including preparation and study on their own ahead of time and a mutual committment and enjoyment of getting at the meaning of texts.
I’m talking about the type of small groups, often mixed with men and women, where there is little to no preparation beforehand and the goal is to engage everyone in discussion.
In my experience, these types of groups, when engaged in “bible studies” on the spot, end up as one of the following:
- dominated by those with more bible knowledge
- with sounds of chirping crickets as everyone sits in silence unable to offer up any answers
- leaving the objective sense of the text behind as everyone fishes for what this verse means to me
Studying the bible, first and foremost, involves arriving at an accurate meaning of the text in front of you. Giving it a cursory read and starting to talk about “what it means to me” just doesn’t cut it.
Arriving at the intended meaning is not easy – it takes time, effort, dedication, and the Spirit. I think we shortchange Scripture, and make people feel unnecessarily self-conscious and guilty, when we expect them to come up with meanings/interpretations of texts on the spot.
Now, this is not to say that these types of small groups are bad – far from it. They are wonderful environments for discussion, application, fellowship, and prayer that is all based on biblical truth; I just don’t think they are good environments for defining what the biblical truth is.
So maybe that’s where these groups should be focused in order to be most effective and helpful – application instead of interpretation.
T. David Gordon put this into words in a spot-on piece that available over at his site. I found myself agreeing the whole way through, as he makes the case that the whole dynamic of small group environments is actually antithetical to the nature and process of studying Scripture as God’s objective revelation.
Check out Small Group Bible Study?